33 Comments
User's avatar
hw's avatar

It's astonishing to witness the downward spiral of the country in the decade since you gave this speech.

This thread (in the comment below) provides a sobering prediction of the next decade should we fail to defeat Republicans on the local, state, and federal levels.

Expand full comment
Marla Kirby's avatar

Wow, sobering facts... It feels like the GOP knows this is its last stand and it has pulled out all the stops to get their way.

Expand full comment
hw's avatar

Agreed...that's why it's crucial to makes the stakes of every election crystal clear.

Flip a few state legislative seats in a purple state, and this will be your future. Vote like Michiganders and gun safety laws will pass, abortion rights will be protected, LGBTQ communities will be protected, etc.

Expand full comment
Susan Troy's avatar

Let's do it.

Expand full comment
Norma Frank's avatar

Trust the women. In the next election, women will be out in droves protecting their rights to their own bodies.

Expand full comment
hw's avatar

Yes, but it's more than one issue. It's guns, book bans, LGBTQ discrimination, union busting, school privatization, drug prices, etc.

So many rights are in jeopardy.

Reforming the Court is an existential imperative.

Expand full comment
Susan Troy's avatar

Yes, I agree with that and I think a lot of women do as well. Abortion will be a big part, but not the only reason women will turn out in droves. Stomping on rights, killing children, and creating even more anxiety for the LGBTQ community, especially teens, and general bigotry don't sit well with most people. Huge tax breaks for the wealthy and no childcare or family leave for working parents aren't cutting it anymore. It is time for a change.

Expand full comment
MATX's avatar

I wish I could have read this when it was first written.

Expand full comment
Marla Kirby's avatar

Same! I was oblivious to the dangerous undercurrents of the Republican party at the time.

Expand full comment
Kathy's avatar

Me three !What keeps me going in Fl is knowing that what DeSantis and others are doing is not sustainable….although we all must try to do our part.💙

Expand full comment
Norma Frank's avatar

This is so perceptive and so right. It is as useful in 2023 as it was in 2012. I used to know a lot of Republicans I had respect for but now I know very few. Even among the elderly, where I live, there are very few Republicans.

Expand full comment
Karen Fetty's avatar

I listened to Resolute Square’s YouTube podcast last night after the Dominion settlement was announced. Maybe that was a mistake. Not even ONE ounce of Hopium. From the podcast: Pandemics and The End of Democracy - What they have in common: “What you say at the beginning will seem alarmist and at the end, will seem inadequate”. They went on to say that Trump will be the nominee and has assembled a very competent campaign staff this time. We should not be complacent. The 2024 election will not be a cakewalk.

Expand full comment
Susan Troy's avatar

No--more like a catfight. I just finished writing another batch of postcards for the CivicsCenter which I learned about through the Seniors Taking Action's speaker series. (I also learned about Hopium through the same series)The CivicsCenter postcards are targeting young people to register to vote and encourage a friend to register as well. Two good organizations to get involved with. I'm an artist, so writing colorful postcards comes naturally.

Expand full comment
B Johnson's avatar

That is totally awesome and cool that you are using your artistic vibe! Thank you

Expand full comment
Susan Troy's avatar

It really helps keep me sane and connected.😊✌️

Expand full comment
B Johnson's avatar

Thanks for the reply. Sanity is precious, but you found your niche.

Expand full comment
John Quinn's avatar

The analysis is sound and certainly appropriately expressed in 2012 and again today. However, part of the dilemma we now face is that the Democrats, as a party, either didn't perceive the transition the Republican Party was making in the 1960's or didn't know how to plan to respond to it effectively. In short, the Republicans have been much more effective long-term strategists than the Democrats have been. I am grateful for your strategic thinking and actions! I hope the Democrats can muster the stamina and resources to defeat this political plague that threatens democracy as well as the well being of people around the globe.

Expand full comment
Susan Troy's avatar

Let's get that message out to the Democrats loud and clear.

Expand full comment
B Johnson's avatar

Though your comment is accurate and has nice sentiment. It sort of sounds as if you are on the sidelines. Like so many of us have been. Myself included unfortunately. Simon’s work means motivation to action.

So I challenge everyone here, take an action, so many to choose from.... donate time or $, join a voter registration groups, get on a local campaign, school board meeting, even talking to a neighbor or co-worker and sharing pro-democracy info like Simon’s. Literally it is our inaction that got us here. Democracy is like a plant, got to tend to it, not just assume it is thriving. I am trying to nurse it back. Peace family!

Expand full comment
Janet Singer's avatar

Still so true today. "It is indeed the great question of American politics now whether and when the Republican Party can modernize and adapt to the new realities of the 21st century, choosing forward over backward." You got it right then and are getting it right now. Bravo!

Expand full comment
Susan Troy's avatar

This was an extremely helpful history lesson. So much attention has now been focused on DT and MAGA that we forget what was happening only a few years earlier. That MAGA has to be crushed is the only option. I still have my "Californians for Obama" tee shirt draped over my desk chair in my studio. It reminds me that politicians can be intelligent, thoughtful, big-hearted people. It also reminds me that Biden showed great courage and generosity of spirit in taking on Trump. Let's move this country forward for everyone.

Expand full comment
Marlene Reil's avatar

Shortly after Romney’s loss in 2012, the GOP commissioned the “Autopsy” that identified some of the issues that resulted in their failure. In 2016, they threw it away against the better judgment of some party members & went all in on the strategy you outlined. Since then, Trump, Fox & the machinery managed to gain ground in the SCOTUS & at the state & local levels. They utilized some of the same Russian PsyOp tactics used by Russia in 2016 to radicalize their dedicated minority base & continue to do so. Some of these people have become almost phobic about POC & LGBTQIA+ people that they feel it necessary to have a firearm at the ready at all times. This aspect of the GOP’s direction was unfathomable in 2012 and represents a serious threat to public safety & to the continuation of democracy.

Expand full comment
Susan Troy's avatar

That's incredibly sad and dangerous. And it is up to all of us to stop it.

Expand full comment
Bruce Waln's avatar

Prescient and so clearly stated. I wish I'd known of you years ago, Simon!

Expand full comment
Susan Garrity Benton's avatar

I just looked at twitter for about 20min. and it felt like I was in Dante ‘s Ninth Circle of Hell. It’s non-

stop lies & ludicrous propaganda and it’s doing serious damage to our country. It also feels like Trump is calling the shots, manipulating everyone in his party to be beyond extreme.

Expand full comment
B Johnson's avatar

Simon today talked about Twitter and Musk canceling users who try to link to their Substack like he has attempted. It is an attack on our 1st Amendment. Check out Simon’s update from today. It will make you feel better. And check out this vid from NoLieBTC of Gov Gavin Newsome. He has a dose of Hopium! See Below

Expand full comment
B Johnson's avatar

Today’s Political Brief from Simon https://www.youtube.com/live/XcCXgZAbDys?feature=share

Expand full comment
Lonnie E's avatar

Four proven steps stop totalitarian dictators. Overcome fear with courage and take action.

"MAGA GOP MASS PSYCHOSIS - How an Entire Population Becomes MENTALLY ILL" and How to Prevent It

❤️ Discredit totalitarian propaganda everywhere

🤣 Mock MAGA GOP worship of dictators

❤️ Promote moral organizations

❤️ Actions by everyone creates freedom

https://youtu.be/09maaUaRT4M

Expand full comment
B Johnson's avatar

https://youtu.be/C6bX3EwdGEw Gov Gavin Newsom on NoLieBTC from about 11 days ago. He has Hopium. Let it play as you make supper and listen to the whole thing if you can. He understands what is going on.

Expand full comment
Samuel Freeman's avatar

Rosenberg has a reasonably good historical summary, but did not seem to have much of a grasp of the realities of 2016, and especially not the realities of today. He says not one work about the neo-liberalism that has dominated the Democratic party since the Clinton presidency. He does not seem to understand the reason we were cursed with Donald Trump is a direct consequence of those neo-liberal policies. The pursuit of neo-liberal policies and programs by the Democratic party over the past, roughly, 40 years has enabled the fascists to gain increasing control over the Republican party such that today, the Republican party essentially is a fascist party. Yet not one word about fascism or fascist control of the Republican party.

As for the growing Democratic vote by Hispanics and African Americans, he obviously was wrong given how Hispanics have been turning toward Republicans, as evidenced by the 2020 and 2022 vote.

With political insight this poor, it is no wonder we stand on the cusp of Nazi Germany 2.0.

Expand full comment
Simon Rosenberg's avatar

This article was written in 2012, so yes it would have not addressed things which happened in 2016 or 2022.

Expand full comment
Mindi Epstein's avatar

I cannot bear this.

https://www.cnn.com/politics/live-news/trump-zelensky-news-02-28-25/index.html

This cannot be allowed to continue happening.

Expand full comment