Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Deborah Potter's avatar

Today I responded to questions in the NYT that were posed yesterday: What are you looking forward to in 2026 and what gives you hope? by editor Lauren Jackson. I wrote about the 250th anniversary of our nation next year and the wave of political change that is coming. The theme of my response is that 2026 will be a year “where our patriotism will be celebrated and shine brightly” as “the next phase of our glorious renewal will begin.” https://www.nytimes.com/2025/12/15/briefing/what-you-hope-for-in-2026.html?unlocked_article_code=1.9E8.FxxH.kHgb2ZbCIJ_U&smid=url-share

Expand full comment
Pamela Frazier's avatar

I got my TNR/Miller homework done.

I really don’t think this one is all that complicated. Miller is basically a Nazi. What’s changed is that Jews get to be white this round.

Racial categories are made up. We make them up and decide who fits in them. So, they evolve over time and vary from one geographic or cultural region to another.

The Jews became white in the latter half of the 20th century. They weren’t the first group to make the transition: it happened for the Irish and Italians too, before them. The scapegoated other is now immigrants of color and their progeny.

Of course the right (and left) still has lots of anti-semitism going on. Ex/ Charlottesville, Nick Fuentes, Laura Loomer (also, Tim Snyder does a great job explaining how Trump’s attitude toward Zelensky is rooted in anti-semitism).

I could be wrong about this, but it doesn’t seem like the far right’s contemporary anti-semitism is based in a belief that Jews are excluded from whiteness.

Miller believes in the superiority of white people and he will carry on with his mass incarceration + mass deportation ethnic cleansing campaign as far as he can. He believes that becoming majority-minority is an existential threat to the west and that it must be stopped at all costs. Violent border policies must be used to keep any more people from Central and South America, Africa, and Middle East and Asia excluded.

As the thinking goes, the white birth rate must go up and —remember eugenics?— coercive policies must be used to control proliferation of nonwhites already here: disproportionate incarceration of women of color for miscarriages or other abortion ban breaches (this part is currently happening at the red state level), forced sterilization (remember the nonconsensual hysterectomies that accompanied family separation in Trump 1.0?).

It took nearly a decade of Nazi history to get to the gas chambers. I wouldn’t be the slightest bit surprised to see Miller escalate to mass murder if given the chance.

CECOT was obviously Dachau. The foreign gulag innovation was conceived as a way to remove targets from the protective arm of American law. Kilmar and Andry were test subjects- to see how rapidly and successfully an international pipeline of forced disappearances could be established in conjunction with friendly dictators or African countries easily coerced into taking and incarcerating and disappearing human bodies removed from the North American continent.

The CECOT scheme also features historical echoes of: re-establishment of a trans-continental slave trade, and the Bush Wars blacksites and outsourcing of torture. There isn’t anything more important than making sure the CECOT scheme fails. We are incredibly fortunate that Andry is now home with his parents and Kilmar is now home with his wife.

But where are the ~1,200 who went missing from Alligator Auschwitz? I just won’t be surprised at the discovery of mass graves. That’s clearly the direction Miller is going.

Yes, it can happen here. It is happening here. This is a basic premise of Holocaust education as I received it: accept the truth that it can happen again anywhere anytime, and proceed accordingly.

First they came for Andry and Kilmar, and I spoke the fuck up immediately because that’s the vow I had taken.

“The homegrowns are next…”

Expand full comment
43 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?