Discussion about this post

User's avatar
SteveG's avatar

This is the type of post that gives me hop(e)ium that 2024 will NOT be the end of our democracy. Thank you Simon. Glad to be a subscriber.

Expand full comment
Theodora30's avatar

The mainstream “liberal” media, with a few exceptions like Lawrence O’Donnell, is again miserably failing our democracy with its simple minded groupthink coverage. Matt Robeson and Paul Hodes had an even more in depth conversation than Mr. O’Donnell’s and Mr. Rosenberg’s above analyzing what the Iowa results really tell us about Trump’s strength and how the mainstream media completely ignored these alternate, valid interpretations.

Matt Robeson has also written about this in Newsweek:

“No, Trump Did Not 'Conquer Iowa.'

How the Media Botched Election Coverage—Again “

Robeson also points out that 62% of the Iowa caucus voters said they would find Trump fit for office even if convicted and 32% said they would not. His take:

“ So, one-third of the country's most dedicated core of Republican base voters say that they will abandon Trump if he loses any of these cases, a breathtaking vulnerability for a candidate. And this nugget is not only buried inside an article about his political strength titled "Trump trounces in Iowa," but is also constructed so as to suggest that this is a sign of how devoted his support is?”

Robeson also points out that the voters who did turn out are the most MAGA voters, a fact which the caucus entrance polls made clear, yet Trump only got 51% of their votes. Almost half of those voters wanted someone else but the mainstream media chose to frame framed results as a huge victory for Trump. That is blatant media malpractice — as is treating the deeply undemocratic caucus results as massively important and representative of what the majority of voters want.

Robeson puts the results in perspective with this thought experiment:

“What if Joe Biden had gotten only half the votes of caucus-goers in Iowa. What would the headlines say? "Commanding victory"? Not on your life. How about a million thesaurus searches for variations on "Biden stumbles?" “

Robison followed his thought experiment with a couple of alternative, far more accurate, headlines:

“Trump Falters As Half of Republicans Turn Against Him" and

“Questions Fly as Trump Barely Clears 50 Percent in Iowa?"

https://www.newsweek.com/no-trump-did-not-conquer-iowa-how-media-botched-election-coverageagain-opinion-1861226

Contrary to what journalists repeatedly proclaim, mainstream media coverage does a lot to bias the public’s perception of reality and to shape our elections.

Expand full comment
40 more comments...

No posts