Discussion about this post

User's avatar
gerri caldarola's avatar

I don't understand why the Dem establishment and Janet Mills can't throw their weight behind a newer candidate... does Maine really want a freshman 77 year old senator. Is that the only way we can win in Maine? (that's a real question" -- because it looks like Schumer is again hoping to stay in power himself, to not make change, to continue to look backwards. But, then, I am not a Maine voter.

Expand full comment
JOHN BUCKHOLZ's avatar

As a resident of NYC, it strikes me that the institutional party is slow to understand the messages that resonate with the voting public. I'm concerned about Mills's age...but that's not the end of it. After all, one of the most popular politicians (net favorability) in America is 84.

But the Bernie comparison is relevant for a different reason. Polling seems to systemically underestimate the appeal of populism. Before the June primary here, the question was whether Mamdani might gain enough 2nd and 3rd-choice RCVs to catch Andrew Cuomo; he beat Andrew decisively in the first round and on the basis of 1st-choice votes, dramatically outperforming all available polling. And I suspect Platner would be the same thing.

Mills wins the head-to-head now because she is the sitting Governor. She's stood up to Trump and been a good governor. Almost everyone in Maine knows who she is. Until a few weeks ago, by contrast, only terminally online people knew who Platner was. But if he continues to run on affordability, his campaign will have more salience. The worst thing the party could do now would be to try to preordain a winner.

Expand full comment
98 more comments...

No posts